On the surface, Holly Holm’s first title defense as women’s bantamweight champion at UFC 196 seemed like a warm-up match. Taking on Miesha Tate, who had been soundly defeated twice by Ronda Rousey, the unbeatable champion that Holm dethroned, there was no question who the underdog in this match was.
Continuing the trend of the unexpected developing in the women’s division, Tate has now staked her claim, reigning on top with the most prestigious title in female mixed martial arts. The shocking win, which was attained through a fifth-round submission choke hold, shook UFC to its core.
A rematch between Holm and Rousey would have resulted in a significant event that would have likely resulted in record revenues for the women’s division. There were definitely visions of Rousey-Holm being the Ali-Frazier of women’s mixed martial arts, an epic rivalry that would have only strengthened the role of UFC’s women’s division.
Instead, the possibility of an eventual Tate vs. Rousey match shall hold no appeal. Unless Rousey enters such a match unprepared or out of shape, the reality is that Tate will struggle to mount a strategic attack against a fighter who has dominated her. In addition, a defeat of Tate would seem a hollow victory for Rousey, as it was Holm that she needed to avenge her loss to.
Holm’s future in UFC is one that is unknown as Tate’s presence contributes to a bizarre triangle of drama for the women’s division. As the third women’s champion in the last six months, Tate does not really have an opponent to prepare for yet. Rousey has not declared when she will return. If Rousey does not return by year-end, Holm could face a rematch situation with Tate.
In reality, Holm deserves the chance at a rematch. Although she claims it was her decision to fight Tate before Rousey, one could understand that it may have been her prerogative to be seen as a fighting champion, rather than sight casually idle and wait for the big payday against Rousey. Should such a rematch with Tate occur, it would definitely be the fight to save Holm’s career. With due deference to Holm, known as “The Preacher’s Daughter”, she now faces the predicament of being considered a one-and-done champion, similar to James “Buster” Douglas, who was immortalized for his defeat of Mike Tyson.
Meanwhile, Tate is certainly trying to stimulate interest on a possible renewed rivalry with Rousey, while proving that she is worthy of the moniker of champion. While Rousey posed for the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue following her loss to Holm, it only adds ammunition to Tate’s weaponry of words. Calling Rousey a broken woman, criticizing a pereceived softer persona, Tate has proceeded to call her the B-word and making comments about her body odor.
The only statement that will have any value is defeating her in the cage. Even if Rousey is considered kinder and gentler, Tate’s words may push her buttons, reigniting an intensity which may result in Tate facing her downfall. While Tate deserves to be admired for bouncing back from losses to Rousey, able to climb to the top of her profession and become a champion after a career that seemed in decline, her lack of humility may only serve to contribute towards another title change, rather than establishing a legacy.